Students for Liberty, September 25th 2013.
From the time of the presidency of Theodore Roosevelt, politicians at the federal level have been pushing for legislation and regulation that serves to protect the environment. When TR nationalized the Parks Services in the 1906 American Antiquities Act, he was the first president to ever enforce environmental legislation (1). Since then, American presidents have enacted more regulation on both large corporations and the American people, most of the legislation making sense for both sides. However, in recent years as climate change has become part of the political and social vernacular, there are those who clamor for even more governmental regulation that has cost the American taxpayers hundreds of billions of dollars. In 2012, federal environmental regulations cost the American government more than $216 billion in regulatory government costs, and amounted to a year's worth of paperwork for more than 40,000 federal employees (2). With well over half the country opposed to raising federal taxes, the current regulatory system is not a sustainable long-term solution (3).
In 1991, Eco-friendly capitalist economists Donald Leal and Terry Anderson published a book, entitled Free Market Environmentalism. In the book, Leal and Anderson argued that deregulating the economy and letting the educated consumer decide their own ecological path, rather than relying on government interference in the free market, will help the environment more than any governing force short of totalitarianism (4). In small doses, the results of FME have been overwhelmingly positive. Entrepreneurship and ingenuity led by free market environmentalists has restored grazing rights for over 500,000 acres worth of bison in Yellowstone National Park, and helped to bring about fishery management zones in India where the government failed (5). If trends like these continue on a larger scale, free market environmentalism could spur the next great innovation in saving the planet.
There are several ways in which free-market environmentalism relates to this course. Firstly, FME has emerged as a response to the environmental concerns that plague our world today, and has been a much-talked about phenomenon in recent years as an alternative to corporate punishment. Additionally, free market environmentalism could serve to increase cooperation between governments and large businesses. FME also forces those in the business world to recognize the impact that humans have on the environment, and stresses the importance of protecting our planet with real-world solutions, Lastly, free-market environmentalism encourages us as consumers to buy the most Eco-conscious materials that we can buy and to help make our world more sustainable.
As for me, I personally think that FME is a realistic solution that could make a big difference in helping the environment. Throughout history, when humans have been able to harness their full potential, we have seen the most innovation to further progress us as a species. It is true that the steps taken by Roosevelt and Presidents Johnson, Nixon and Ford were necessary and remain so today. However, I am of the belief that we can't let bureaucracy quell innovation in the market, and that continued government overreach and interference in the private sector rarely works well in the long run. Ultimately, I think that cooperation between environmental entrepreneurs who wish to see a longer-lasting, sustainable planet and a government that allows them to do so is the best solution to our climate change problem.
Citations:
1. United States. National Park Service.
"Theodore Roosevelt and Conservation." National Parks Service. U.S. Department of the Interior, 15 Jan. 2016. Web. 26 Jan.
2016.
2.
Anderson,
Terry. "Free Market Environmentalism." Hoover Institution.
N.p., 19 Feb. 2015. Web. 26 Jan. 2016.
3.
"Taxes." Gallup.com. Gallup,
n.d. Web. 26 Jan. 2016.
4. Anderson, Terry. "Free Market Environmentalism." Hoover Institution. N.p., 19 Feb. 2015. Web. 26 Jan. 2016.
5. Anderson, Terry. "Free Market Environmentalism." Hoover Institution. N.p., 19 Feb. 2015. Web. 26 Jan. 2016.
So often, material on this subject is from the opposite viewpoint. I appreciate that you would choose something controversial, like this subject, argue it well and support it with strong sources. Great job!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete